Nei til vindkraft

Diskusjon om generelle politiske temaer, som ikke passer inn under innenriks/utenriks.

Nei til vindkraft

Innlegg Vegard Martinsen 05 Nov 2011, 08:11

DLF vil selvsagt ikke forby vindkraft, men vi vil være imot alle subsider til dette tullet, og vi vil trekke frem gode argumentre mot vindkrat, argumenter som MSM sjelden eller aldri never.

Men iblant kommer de frem, som f.eks. her:


Which would you rather have in the view from your house? A thing about the size of a domestic garage, or eight towers twice the height of Nelson’s column with blades noisily thrumming the air? The energy they can produce over ten years is similar: eight wind turbines of 2.5 megawatts (working at about 25 per cent capacity) roughly equal the output of an average Pennsylvania shale gas well (converted to electricity at 50 per cent efficiency) in its first ten years.

Difficult choice? Let’s make it easier. The gas well can be hidden in a hollow, behind a hedge. The eight wind turbines must be on top of hills, because that is where the wind blows, visible for up to 40 miles. And they require the construction of new pylons marching to the towns; the gas well is connected by an underground pipe.

Unpersuaded? Wind turbines slice thousands of birds of prey in half every year, including white-tailed eagles in Norway, golden eagles in California, wedge-tailed eagles in Tasmania. There’s a video on YouTube of one winging a griffon vulture in Crete. According to a study in Pennsylvania, a wind farm with eight turbines would kill about 200 bats a year. The pressure wave from the passing blade just implodes the little creatures’ lungs. You and I can go to jail for harming bats or eagles; wind companies are immune.

http://www.spectator.co.uk/essays/73089 ... tury.thtml
Vegard Martinsen
 
Innlegg: 7867
Registrert: 07 Sep 2003, 12:07

Re: Nei til vindkraft

Innlegg stian 05 Nov 2011, 17:36

Vindkraft fungerer kun når det er vind også. En vindpark som i gjennomsnitet klarer 20mw vil fremdeles ha behov for en mer stabil energikilde for å dekke kraftbehovet når vindparken er uten vind. Noe som i teksten over antakeligvis må betyr at du også må ha en "average Pennsylvania shale gas well". Det blir en dyr investering dersom man kun skal bygge en park. Og kostnadden per vindmølle, samt vedlikehold er høyere enn de fleste andre methoder.

Hva har egentlig miljøbevegelsen å si om ørner, jeg vet det har vært et problem på andøy.
Partimedlem.
stian
 
Innlegg: 292
Registrert: 06 Apr 2011, 20:22
Bosted: Tromsø

Re: Nei til vindkraft

Innlegg QIQrrr 05 Nov 2011, 17:58

stian skrev:Hva har egentlig miljøbevegelsen å si om ørner...

Godt spørsmål. Jeg har ikke hørt noe fra miljøbevegelsen når det gjelder ørner. Mange ser på ørnen som et symbol på individuell frihet, og individuell frihet er jo som kjent en vederstyggelighet som miljøbevegelsen vil ha seg frabedt. Ufyselige flaggermus synes derimot å vekke morsinstinktet i naturfolket:

    The Tribune Democrat, October 17, 2011: Night operation of the windmills in the North Allegheny Windpower Project has been halted following discovery of a dead Indiana bat under one of the turbines, an official with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service said Monday. The finding marks only the second location where an Indiana bat has been found dead under a wind turbine. Two Indiana bats were found under turbines in the Mid-west, said Clint Riley, supervisor for Fish and Wildlife’s Pennsylvania field office. “While finding the dead bat is not good news for any of us, it does show the monitoring works,” Riley said from his State College office. The find is significant because the Indiana bat is an endangered species and is protected by the federal Endangered Species Act - Windmills to shut at night following demise of rare bat
Børge Svanstrøm Amundsen

"Atlas was permitted the opinion that he was at liberty, if he wished, to drop the Earth and creep away; but this opinion was all that he was permitted" - Franz Kafka
Brukerens avatar
QIQrrr
 
Innlegg: 4439
Registrert: 20 Mai 2004, 23:33

Re: Nei til vindkraft

Innlegg QIQrrr 12 Des 2011, 07:18

Utilsiktet samtidskunst fra Skottland:

    Bilde
Børge Svanstrøm Amundsen

"Atlas was permitted the opinion that he was at liberty, if he wished, to drop the Earth and creep away; but this opinion was all that he was permitted" - Franz Kafka
Brukerens avatar
QIQrrr
 
Innlegg: 4439
Registrert: 20 Mai 2004, 23:33

Re: Nei til vindkraft

Innlegg QIQrrr 08 Jan 2012, 02:03

Gone with the Wind:

    Mail Online, January 6, 2012: First there were the wind farms that had to be shut down if it got a bit blowy. Then there was the turbine that burst into flames in a gale a month ago. And now three turbines have been wrecked in the latest bout of rough weather – sweeping away any remaining illusions that strong winds simply mean more electricity being generated - Wind turbines can't cope with UK weather as 3 more blown to pieces

Børge Svanstrøm Amundsen

"Atlas was permitted the opinion that he was at liberty, if he wished, to drop the Earth and creep away; but this opinion was all that he was permitted" - Franz Kafka
Brukerens avatar
QIQrrr
 
Innlegg: 4439
Registrert: 20 Mai 2004, 23:33

Re: Nei til vindkraft

Innlegg Ultima_Thule 16 Des 2013, 00:11

Wind Energy's Ghosts, American Thinker
Ultima_Thule
 
Innlegg: 168
Registrert: 16 Jan 2010, 09:15


Gå til Generell politikk

Hvem er i forumet

Brukere som leser i dette forumet: Ingen registrerte brukere og 7 gjester

cron